Don’t miss Celebrity Myxer’s recap of Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 5 “Chapter Five: The Night He Came Home.” Desperate to keep her mother’s house, Imogen throws a Halloween party to raise cash, but the presence of an unwanted guest casts a shadow on the celebration. Here’s what you missed!
Stay right here, stay mixed in for exclusive updates! Drop your email to get insights into your inbox…
Watch Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 5 “Chapter Five: The Night He Came Home”
Previously on Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 4, after their punishment comes to an end, the girls cement their friendship when Imogen needs them most. Meanwhile, Noa finds herself in A’s crosshairs.
Warning… Spoilers below!
On Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 5, flashback to Halloween 1999, and Angela is out with her friends. She is talked into pulling a prank, and as Angela walks up to the house, her friends drive away, leaving Angela all alone. Flash forward, and Imogen is asking her friends what their moms could have done to Angela. Imogen is convinced the missing diary pages will link her mom to Angela.
Throwing A Party
Tabitha is angry at Chip for filming her Psycho scene without her. When the girls search Imogen’s old house, Faran finds the missing pages burnt in the fireplace.
Henry tells Faran that Kelly does have a scar on her foot. Mouse video chats with Steven, who has lost a daughter, Rachel, and sets up a meet. Imogen finds the quilt her mom made for the baby and decides to throw a Halloween party to help raise money so she can buy the house.
Faran tells her dance teacher that she believes Kelly is really Karen because of the scar, and her teacher informs her that Kelly has multiple scars everywhere because she is a cutter. Tabitha picks up her last paycheck from the theater, and Wes apologizes for his behavior. Tabitha agrees to come back and work for him.
The theater is packed for the scary movie marathon, and Mouse puts her foot down with her mom to be allowed to go to the party. Faran invites Kelly out to eat.
At the restaurant, Faran notices a cut on Kelly’s hand and offers her some support. She believes it is really Kelly the cutter. She invites Kelly to Imogen’s Halloween party. At the party, people show up, and A breaks into Imogen’s cellar.
Tabitha is livid when she sees Tyler at the party. Mouse meets up with Steven, who takes her trick or treating. He calls Mouse Rachel and tells her that she can call him dad.
A Broken Nose
Henry kisses Faran at the party, and Steven gives Mouse a ride to the party. He drops him off a block away so that nobody will see them together. Imogen receives a call about Angela but cannot hear over the music. Faran sees Kelly kiss Greg.
Chip tells Tabitha that he is so sorry and wants her to reshoot the scene because it is her vision, and he is wrong. Faran confronts Kelly about kissing Chip and tells her that she really believes that Kelly died.
Mouse gets high with Ash and heads to get snacks. Tyler starts harassing her, and Tabitha loses it. She punches Tyler in the face and breaks his nose.
A Deadly Bathroom
Tyler runs to the bathroom where Imogen’s mom killed herself, and A follows him. A kills Tyler and carries his body out to his van. All the girls are so proud of Tabitha for standing up to Tyler.
Imogen receives another call about her mom and Angela, and the man wants to meet face-to-face. Mouse prints out the picture of her and Steven and puts it with a pile of pictures. Faran is told that Kelly will be dancing the lead in the Black Swan and Faran is to leave Kelly alone and not harass her about Karen.
Imogen asks Tabitha why she has so much hate towards Tyler. Tabitha explains that she went to a party in the woods over the summer and something happened to her. Imogen tells Tabitha that something happened to her too!
What did you think of Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 5? Let’s talk about Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin in the comments below! Missed any of the episodes? Catch up with our recaps!
Air Date: August 4, 2022
Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Cast
- Bailee Madison as Imogen Adams
- Chandler Kinney as Tabitha “Tabby” Hayworth
- Maia Reficco as Noa Olivar
- Zaria Simone as Faran Bryant
- Malia Pyles as Minnie “Mouse” Honrada
- Alex Aiono as Shawn
- Mallory Bechtel as Karen/Kelly Beasley
- Eric Johnson as Sheriff Beasley
Catch a new episode each week on HBO Max, check out listings dates below. Stay right here, stay mixed in for Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 6, stay tuned! Drop your email to get insights into your inbox…
Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Episode Guide
|1||10||“Chapter Ten: Final Girls” Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season Finale||August 18, 2022|
|1||9||“Chapter Nine: Dead and Buried”||August 18, 2022|
|1||8||“Chapter Eight: Bad Blood”||August 18, 2022|
|1||7||“Chapter Seven: Carnival of Souls”||August 11, 2022|
|1||6||“Chapter Six: Scars”||August 11, 2022|
|1||5||“Chapter Five: The Night He Came Home”||August 4, 2022|
|1||4||“Chapter Four: The Fe(male) Gaze”||August 4, 2022|
|1||3||“Chapter Three: Aftermath”||July 28, 2022|
|1||2||“Chapter Two: The Spirit Queen”||July 28, 2022|
|1||1||“Chapter One: Spirit Week” Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin Season 1 Premiere||July 28, 2022|
Photo credit: HBO Max